The following is a condensed and edited version of my 2002 trip to Palestine
journal entries, published in the March 2004 issue of Musicworks
Magazine. - JF]
In November 2002, I visited East Jerusalem, Ramallah and Bethlehem to perform concerts
and hold workshops with young music students, in conjunction with the National Conservatory
of Palestine and the Yabous Concert Series ("Yabous" is Arabic for "Jebusite",
the Canaanite founders of Jerusalem and one of the ancestors of modern-day Palestinians).
It was a great opportunity for me to make a small contribution to the arts scene
in the country of my parents’ origin.
Since its founding in 1993, the National Conservatory has been trying to continue
to foster the artistic life in the West Bank through lessons, workshops and concerts
of resident and guest artists. Tuition fees are about $600 USD per academic year,
but for those who cannot afford to pay there are scholarships available, made possible
by donations from local and international organisations. Though classes are often
cancelled due to army incursions and suffocating curfews, with true mettle the teachers
and performers often break curfew at high personal risk to give the children a desperately
needed education. One example occurred during a concert in Ramallah in October 2003,
when musicians visiting from Germany continued playing despite the bombing and shelling
of an incursion outside.
It was my second time performing in the West Bank, the first being in 1999, before
the Second Intifada, when Ramallah was starting to blossom its creative potential
with artists of all sorts from the Palestinian diaspora returning from abroad to
build a rich and kaleidoscopic arts scene. Cafes and restaurants were popping up
everywhere, and seemed to me just an inkling of what could be possible if the Occupation
ended completely and finally. New Conservatory branches had been planned in Gaza
and Nablus but the deeper entrenchment of the occupation since the second Intifada
has made such plans impossible. Their curriculum and concerts place an equal emphasis
on both Western and Arabic classical music, with local as well as international
instructors who donate at least a year of their time to provide some hope to children
living in dangerous and impoverished conditions. One success story is that of Ramzi
Hussein, who in 1987 at eight years of age was throwing stones at Israeli soldiers
outside his home in the el-Amari refugee camp. Thanks to scholarship donations he
was able to enrol at the conservatory for 4 years, and is now continuing his viola
studies at a regional conservatory in France.
My 1999 recital in Ramallah had been an assortment of works by Bach, Messiaen,
Andriessen, Charles Kœchlin, Shostakovich, and a composition of my own entitled “Soul
Departing Body”. Since then, however, my live performances had changed to a hybrid
of contemporary art music, free improvisation, minimalism and electronica/drum’n’bass.
It was a bit of a risk for the artistic director, Suhail Khoury, to take, as the
audiences I would be performing for would be quite unused to the agressively beat-heavy
element of so-called "Intelligent Dance Music". After some discussion
I convinced him that it would be more of a sincere and unique contribution to showcase
the sort of things I am currently working on, and may stimulate some new curiosities
and interests in the students.
All aspects of Palestinian society have been devastated by the 36-year Israeli
occupation, and the Conservatory is not an exception. Oriental Music Department head
and oud instructor Ahmad Khatib was arrested on April 8, 2002 and released the next
day. Hand-cuffed and blind-folded, during this time he was used as a human shield
by the Israeli Defense Force (IDF). It should be mentioned that Khatib’s residential
neighborhood had gone without water or electricity for a whole week. Senior staff
member Muhammad Yacoub was rounded up with others from his neighborhood and arrested
(without explanation or charge) in Al-Bireh on April 29, 2002 and transported in
buses to an unknown place. He and the other prisoners were placed in a dried-up
septic tank and left there for 24 hours. They were later put in damp tents for another
4 days, sleeping on damp mattresses placed directly on the muddy ground.
My first concert was at the YWCA in east Jerusalem, the same building in which
the Conservatory’s main offices are located. My set up consisted of my laptop G4,
a Mackie 1202 mixer, an Emagic 6-output soundcard, a Korg Kaos Pad (a touch-sensitive
effects unit) and a miked grand piano. On the computer I would run sequences pre-composed
in Logic Audio, using software samplers and synthesizers such as Reaktor and the
EXS24, and each sound was routed to one of 6 outputs, which could be selectively
affected through delays and reverbs on the Kaos Pad.
My compositions were mostly inspired by an interest in Canaanite, Philistine
and Phoenician mythology. I started with an ambient piece called ‘The Fountain of
Astarte’ in which I improvised over synth drones, followed by ‘Flame of Canaan’,
which was a drum’n’bass sequence using looped fragments of Melkite (Arabic/Syriac
Greek-Catholic) and Maronite chants, ‘Ud and dumbek samples layered onto high-tempo
breakbeats. In a composition called ‘Bas-Relief’ I used samples from Messiaen’s ‘Illuminations
of the Beyond’ and Cage’s Sonatas and Interludes, also fused with intricate drum
programming.
In the next two days I held workshops for the piano students of the Jerusalem
and Ramallah branches. After hearing and critiquing some pieces, I bought out my
laptop and showed a few examples of the software synthesizer sequences and samples
I had used. I spoke about Minimalist and Ambient music, and explained the basic principles
of Atonal and Twelve-tone music, performing examples at the piano which yielded reactions
from fascination to aversion. I gave a few students an improvisation exercise to
try in front of the class, and after their initial trepidation they became engaged
with it. At the end we made a map of a musical form which had several contrasting
sections and characteristics (tempo, range, harmonies, dynamics, etc.) which I then
improvised for them. Many of them are already familiar with Taqasim, or Arabic style
improvisations, using the different modes or Maqâmât, so they were interested
to hear something improvised in a completely different style.
Bethlehem was quite a different experience. The drive from E. Jerusalem to Bethlehem,
without checkpoints, would as short as 10 minutes if travel was unrestricted. Add
checkpoints and detours and you have a harrowing two-hour experience. I was exasperated
when finally arriving, but the students weren't; disruption of their lives is a regular
occurence, as towns are often sealed off, undergoing an army incursion, or under
curfew, and classes are constantly being cancelled.
The Bethlehem branch is in a converted church, and some of the rehearsal spaces
are in cavernous rooms underground. My workshop there followed the same format, with
one student performing Chopin’s A-flat major Polonaise. They also took willingly
to the improvisation excerises, one of which was to slowly explore the different
permutations and voicings of a 5-note chord of their choosing, sustain pedal depressed,
over a five minute period. I wished I could teach more classes there, as they would
learn so quickly and I'm sure that not after long they would be surprising me with
their improvisational ideas.
My concert was to be held at the Bethlehem Peace Centre, a beautiful and spacious
building located in Manger Square, funded by a donation from the Swedish government.
In the afternoon I had a meeting with one of the directors, curious to know first
hand what transpired in this particular building during the April 2002 Israeli invasion.
I think it is important to note the details of what happened here, because if one
takes the story of the Peace Centre and applies it to a broader context, it will
provide an inkling of what has happened in practically every other building and home
in Palestine.
The Centre was invaded 3 times since the outbreak of the 2nd Intifada in 2000.
The final, full-scale invasion in April 2002 lasted an astounding 38 days, during
which also all of Manger Square and it's adjacent neighbourhood were under complete,
24 hour curfew. The Israeli Defence Force (IDF) inflicted $200,000 USD of vandalism
and theft: the back door was dynamited, 138 doors were destroyed, all toilets broken,
all chairs slashed open, all computers, printers, video projectors, telephones and
intercoms were looted. The soldiers urinated, vomited and defecated on the walls
and floors. Just in case the beautiful Bösendorfer that I was to play was up
to no good, it was also vandalised for good measure. Left behind as a gift to the
Centre by the Vienna Boys Choir after performance at the Bethlehem 2000 celebrations,
even the screws were stolen from the lid and strings snapped as a final act of spite.
The schoolmaster of the Bethlehem branch took me around town, showed me Gilo,
the ever-expanding Israeli settlement across the valley, and Dheisheh refugee camp,
a makeshift shadow-ghetto truncated onto Bethlehem.
It is worth noting that residents of subsidised and fortified Gilo (at least
10,000 people), pay about 1/2 a Shekel for every cubic meter of water consumed, while
Palestinians living in Bethlehem and surrounding areas (about 60,000 people), pay
roughly 4 Shekels per cubic meter. Hence Gilo enjoys lush lawns and swimming pools
while Palestinian hospitals sometimes have trouble affording enough water to wash
their linen (for details on topics such as water, environment, refugees, living conditions,
etc., visit www.passia.org).
The concert that night was well attended, with about 250 people in the Peace
Centre’s spacious hall, but my performance didn’t unfold as I intended; after my
computer screen froze I paniced internally, trying to keep my focus with solo piano
improvisations. I managed to get into a somewhat more creative space after the intermission,
but after the concert the audience reaction was appreciative but slightly subdued.
Even though the overall preferences of the Bethlehem crowd may have been a touch
conservative compared to Jerusalem or Ramallah, they had listened intently, so it
was all the more unfortunate that I didn’t make the strongest case for not only my
music but for the selection of disparate elements I was proposing to mix.
The next day I was off to Ramallah, passing through the permanantly congested
Kalandia checkpoint. Here, like so many other checkpoints in the Occupied Territories,
Palestinians line up in droves, hoping to avoid harrasment and humiliation by IDF
soldiers and be allowed to pass through, sometimes after waiting weeks for a permit,
just to visit a relative in an adjacent town.
The last concert was held in the Sakakini Cultural Centre, a three-story building
that serves as an art gallery as well as a small scale concert venue seating no more
than one hundred people. Incedentally, this building had also been vandalised and
looted by the IDF in April 2002 (also, the Friends’ Girls School, where I had given
my 1999 concert, had been partially destroyed by tank shells).
I think it is essential to ask why such insitutions as the Peace Centre and the
Sakakini are targeted by the IDF. The answerdoes not lie in the convenient excuse
of rooting out the so called “Terrorist Infrastructure”, but rather in the intention
to destroy the people’s will and hinder the development of Palestinian cultural institutions,
disrupting aspirations in art, music, dance, sculpture and thus further fragmenting
national consciousness. Art gives people something to live for, as well as a vehicle
to emote their frustrations and hopes. Artists and artistic communites contribute
to creating a healthy, robust and forward-looking society, stimulating minds, creating
new ideas, sparking new approaches to life, survival, liberation; this itself is
a profound and fundamental threat that the IDF must quell.
The concert fortunately went very well, the top floor of the Sakakini was filled
with people eager to be fed unfamiliar sounds and experiences, creating an extraordinarily
vibrant and encouraging atmosphere for me to improvise in. To add to the ambience,
the ceiling and walls had been covered with fabrics and adorned with lanterns to
re-create the interior of a bedouin’s tent.
After the concert students and adults were buzzing with questions about where
the sounds came from and how they were created. I wasn’t sure how the audiences would
take to the strong presence of beats and drum sequences in so many of the tracks,
but these were greeted with enthusiastic comments about the variety and complexity
of rhythms and sonorities.
My euphoria came to an abrupt end a few hours later with the sudden shock of
a nearby explosion. It may have been from a tank or helicopter gunship, but sometimes
the IDF induces panic and nervousness on a towns’ population by detonating "Sound"
and/or "Light" bombs. Rather than explode, these stun with sound, or create
relentless and blinding illuminations in the middle of the night. It was a sobering
event to end my trip.
Apart from the joy of performing my music, having fun with the students and visiting
relatives, this experience also allowed me to partake in a kind of musical political
activism in a much more direct way than I could from my home in Toronto. I also kept
an online journal so as to communicate with others what I was observing first-hand,
injustices of which I had only read about from Canada. As to whether the conservatory
students and audiences benefitted from my concerts, I can only be hopeful that it
offered, at the least, a momentary opening for some people to escape their chronic
scenery. My intention was to generate an appetite for different forms of electronic
music, contemporary art music and free improvisation amongst the students and music
community.
Upon returning to Canada I started a small-scale music book drive for the Conservatory,
and many friends and colleagues have generously mailed dozens of used scores, composer
biographies and theory books to their small but budding music library. If you have
any music literature or scores that you think would be of educational value and would
like to donate, please feel free to mail them to: The National Conservatory of Music,
Attn: Suhail Khoury, P.O. Box 66676, E. Jerusalem, Palestine (via Israel). More
information is available though their website at www.birzeit.edu/music (Flash plug-in
needed).